Utilization of Non-Licensed Personnel (Medication Aides, Lifting Teams, Transport Teams)
The most common patient handling approaches in the United States include manual patient lifting, classes in body mechanics, training in safe lifting techniques, and back belts. Surprisingly there is strong evidence that each of these commonly used approaches is not effective in reducing caregiver injuries. A major paradigm shift is needed away from these ineffective approaches towards the following evidennuce-based practices.
The concept of delegation between nurses and UAPs, and the relationship between nurses and UAPs in clinical practice was not broadly studied since the new joint statements issued by the ANA and the NCSBN. Few studies were found in the literature regarding nursing delegation and the relationship between nurses and UAPs. Only few qualitative studies were found on this topic, of which, only one was qualitative in nature. Studies have found that nurses report a lack of knowledge on how to properly delegate activities to UAPs and an insufficient knowledge regarding the UAPs training. Although still responsible for the comprehensive patient care, many nurses expressed frustration with multiple additional responsibilities unrelated to direct bedside care, even if they were assisted during the work by an UAP.
With two states mandating ratios (California and Massachusetts1) and 14 other states requiring either staffing committees or public reporting of nurse staffing levels, the policy focus has been primarily on RNs, with little or no consideration of how CNLP staffing affects nurses’ workloads (Emergency Nurses Association 2014; ANA 2015).On the other hand, Potter et al. (2003) found a negative association between RN and patient care technicians, suggesting a possible substitution effect. More recent studies on the effects of California's nurse staffing law also found decreased use of nurse aides and orderlies associated with increased use of nurses in hospitals attempting to meet the minimum patient‐to‐nurse ratios.
McHugh, M. D. , Kelly L. A., Sloane D. M., and Aiken L. H.. 2011. “Contradicting Fears, California's Nurse‐to‐Patient Mandate Did Not Reduce the Skill Level of the Nursing Workforce in Hospitals.” Health Affairs 30 (7): 1299–306.
Donaldson, N. , Bolton L. B., Aydin C., Brown D., Elashoff J. D., and Sandhu M.. 2005. “Impact of California's Licensed Nurse‐Patient Ratios on Unit‐Level Nurse Staffing and Patient Outcomes.” Policy, Politics, & Nursing Practice 6 (3): 198–210.
Emergency Nurses Association . 2014. “50 State Nurse Safe Staffing Laws”
Potter, P. , Barr N., McSweeney M., and Sledge J.. 2003. “Identifying Nurse Staffing and Patient Outcome Relationships: A Guide for Change in Care Delivery.” Nursing Economics 21 (4): 158.